Do More Detected Cases Mean Leprosy Is Making A Comeback In India? Experts, Government Differ

New Delhi: Leprosy is back in India.

Health officials and activists celebrated 13 years ago when India announced that leprosy had been eliminated as a public health concern. Alarm bells rang as the Central Leprosy Division of the health ministry reported that 135,485 new leprosy cases were detected in India in 2017. That meant every four minutes somebody was diagnosed with leprosy in India. This is nowhere close to elimination.

India will eliminate leprosy by 2018, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley told parliament in a budget speech on February 1, 2017, in an admission that the disease abounds. Activists working in the field say the target is impossible to achieve.

Of the new cases detected, nearly half (67,160) have been diagnosed at an advanced stage. And the number of new detections is high. For instance, in Telangana’s Adilabad district, a village called Kushanpally with 250 houses (1,040 people) turned up 19 cases. “Pockets of high endemicity report thousands of new cases every year,” the World Health Organization (WHO) noted in 2016, adding that in 2015, India had accounted for 60% of the global total of new cases.

There is no reliable pan-India study or survey on the incidence of leprosy, and activists say the government is reluctant to record new cases for fear of losing its ‘elimination’ status.

However, government officials deny this, saying their own efforts have led to improved detection, and increase in the number of cases detected does not mean incidence is increasing.

“No, leprosy is not rising in India, the numbers are rising because we are detecting more cases,” Anil Kumar, deputy director general (Leprosy) at the ministry of health and family welfare, told IndiaSpend.

Full View

Unwanted and neglected

Rachna Kumari was married at 18 and had two children by the time she was 21. Life was good in Munger, Bihar. Her world suddenly collapsed when she was diagnosed with leprosy. Her family disowned her and asked her to leave home.

Heartbroken, she fought with herself to find the courage to battle the disease and reclaim her life, alone. After being cured, she decided to dedicate her life to fighting discrimination in any form. Today, she sits on the panel of the International Federation of Anti-Leprosy Associations that works for leprosy patients. She works with Lepra Society’s Referral Centre in Munger, Bihar. “My dream is for the world to be leprosy-free. I tell every new leprosy patient not to feel ashamed but hold their head high and not have any fear,” she said, “If we all work together with sincerity, we can eradicate leprosy just as we did with polio.”

India has more than 3 million people with deformities caused by leprosy. They are relegated to the margins of society and feel neglected and unwanted, living mostly in 750-odd leprosy colonies. Society largely treats them as social outcasts.

Being infectious, leprosy can spread--if not detected in time, it spreads through skin and peripheral nerves, damaging the nerves of the hands and feet to render them dead to sensation. This naturally leads to disabling injuries. This is why leprosy is feared and stigmatised so much.

Most of us do not contract leprosy as our immune system is strong and we have built a resistance to mycobacterium leprae, the bacterium that causes the disease. It is those with weak immunity that fall prey to it. Invariably, it is the poor who are malnourished and do not have easy access to medical facilities.

Elimination is not eradication

Since India received funding from the WHO to tackle leprosy, it was under pressure to show progress, activists and experts say. The government hurriedly announced in 2005 that leprosy was eliminated--which implies that incidence is one case per 10,000 (0.01%). Some experts questioned the manner in which this elimination was achieved--for instance, by stopping active case-finding (and counting on self-reporting, which invariably leads to under-reporting), and by not counting single-lesion cases (which are considered less serious).

Thanks to India’s vast population, even fewer than “1 in 10,000 cases” can number in the lakhs overall. Despite achieving elimination of leprosy as a public health problem in 2005, India had the largest number of leprosy patients in the world, the WHO noted in 2016.

Also, the ‘one in 10,000’ figure was arrived at by taking an average of all the states, disregarding the vast variations between states. For instance, large and underdeveloped Uttar Pradesh had a high incidence, while developed states such as Kerala had a low figure. Bunching all these together to achieve elimination status proved a costly mistake.

Full View

‘Elimination’ was confused with ‘eradication’--the latter refers to the complete and permanent reduction of new cases to zero--and the threat of leprosy was prematurely considered over. The government machinery that worked for leprosy elimination slackened, and its personnel were transferred to other health departments considered in more urgent need. Front-line workers stopped household visits to identify undetected cases.

Under-reporting of cases

Stoppage of active surveillance after the elimination announcement has led to severe under-reporting of cases in India, studies such as this one from Munger, Bihar, have pointed out.

Finding an increase in ‘heightened disability’ among the new cases detected, a midterm evaluation of the National Leprosy Eradication programme in late 2016 said that this indicated “that the cases are being detected late in the community and there may be several cases which are lying undetected or hidden”. These hidden cases are dangerous because untreated patients are “an active reservoir in the community which transmit the disease to [the] susceptible”, the review said. It also found a large number of children among those detected.

Yet, several activists and researchers who work with leprosy patients told IndiaSpend, while insisting they not be named, that the government is resisting documentation of new cases. They pointed out, for example, that for several years after 2005, the number of new leprosy cases detected hung around the figure of 130,000 annually as it was deliberately kept within the elimination range (0.01% of India’s 1.3 billion population).

Places such as Delhi, Chandigarh, Dadra and Nagar Haveli, Odisha, West Bengal and Lakshadweep, which were at the forefront of elimination targets, are now among the worst affected. Kerala, for instance, which has the best health indicators in India and once had the lowest rates of leprosy, now has a large number of leprosy patients--probably because of the high number of migrant labour that comes in from Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, West Bengal and Odisha, where wages are lower.

Kumar from the health ministry contested these claims, saying a Leprosy Case Detection Campaign conducted in 163 high-endemic districts of India had screened 360 million people in 2016 and 700 million in 2017, which is why the number of cases had increased subsequently.

“We started ASHA based surveillance for leprosy suspects [in 2017] where ASHAs [accredited social health activists] were asked how many people did they screen and report every month so that they remained vigilant,” he said.

He admitted, however, that there has been a shortage of funds. “There are about 125,000 leprosy cases and 800,000 people infected with the bacteria every year, yet they get only Rs 46 crore compared to over Rs 2,000 crores that HIV/AIDS [programme] gets every year,” he said.

“Leprosy has a six-year incubation period which is why I am not claiming leprosy will be eliminated in one or two years,” Kumar said, adding, “If we continue the surveillance and get more funds India can be leprosy-free by 2030.”

Early detection and treatment

For this, early detection and treatment before any disability sets in is important, as is rehabilitation of those who have been disabled so that they can live independently and carve out a dignified life. But society is rife with stigma and discrimination. Health activists have to fight numerous myths that have caught on because of poor understanding of the disease. One such myth is of leprosy being divine punishment for past sins.

Stigma prevents most patients from seeking medical treatment until it is too late, activist Vineeta Shanker, executive director of Sasakawa India Leprosy Foundation, points out. Nerve damage is irreversible and once disabilities set in, social rehabilitation becomes very challenging.

“We have to struggle even with the highly educated as well as opinion makers,” Ashim Chowla, chief executive of Lepra Society, Secunderabad, told IndiaSpend. “Fairly recently, the Pope said that child abuse was like ‘leprosy in our house’. Because of the stigma involved, patients try to hide it. Changing attitudes takes time; even the government does not have the wherewithal to deal with something so complicated and produce quick results. This requires involvement of all stakeholders and drivers of change.”

Recently, parliament passed an amendment to remove discrimination against leprosy patients in various laws, especially those governing marriage and divorce, across faiths. There were 119 such laws, which blatantly discriminated against leprosy patients--for instance, by holding leprosy a valid reason for divorce, and considering leprosy an “incurable and virulent” disease. The government is also working on a draft bill to eliminate discrimination against persons affected by leprosy.

There are practical problems in detection, too. All parts of the patient’s body need to be examined, in good light, but most places where patients are examined are poorly lit. Male staff often shy away from asking women, especially in villages, to take off their clothes for examination. Many women refuse to do so. This means small diseased patches, of which even the patient is unaware, go undetected.

Once detected, the government treats leprosy patients for free. Patients are administered a multidrug therapy--a combination of different drugs--which is very effective and usually cures within six to 12 months.

As essential as early detection and treatment is post-treatment follow-up to detect relapse and identify drug-resistant strains.

The success of the anti-tobacco movement gives Chowla hope. “Leprosy needs something similar with corporate, private institutions and NGOs putting their commitment behind eradicating the disease,” he said. Since leprosy mainly affects the poor, it does not get the attention it deserves. The challenge is to end transmission by detecting cases and immediately putting them on multi-drug therapy, which should be made available even in the remotest parts of India. “There is no solid infrastructure at the moment that is geared to either detect and treat or end discrimination against patients,” he said.

Earlier this year, the Supreme Court directed states and the central government to roll out awareness programmes about leprosy, something India should have proactively done seven years ago when it became a signatory to the United Nations resolution on the elimination of discrimination against persons affected by leprosy and their family members.

The court said campaigns should not use frightening images of leprosy affected people but utilise positive images and stories of those who had been cured. The judgment came as huge relief by focusing attention on the need to urgently deal with the disease, Nikita Sarah, Head of Advocacy, The Leprosy Mission Trust, India, said.

A good workable strategy in India may be to integrate leprosy care with other areas of healthcare so that the perception of it being a dreadful disease that has to be treated separately disappears.

One of the main challenges in the fight against leprosy is that there is no vaccine against it yet, Mary Verghese, Executive Director, The Leprosy Mission Trust India, told IndiaSpend. The only way to end transmission, she said, is to ensure that people know how to recognise early signs and symptoms of leprosy and come in immediately for treatment. Increased resource allocation towards leprosy control is imperative, she said.

Correction: An earlier version of the story said, “Being infectious, leprosy can spread easily.” This is incorrect. Prolonged, close contact with someone with untreated leprosy over many months is needed to catch the disease, according to the United States Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. We regret the error.

Update:

1. On January 4, 2019, this story had been updated and headline changed to reflect the views of Anil Kumar, deputy director general, Central Leprosy Division.
2. On January 7, 2019, Kumar added to his comments through email. We are carrying his statement in full below:

“It is true that India achieved the elimination in year 2005 at National level as per WHO criteria i.e., reduction of Prevalence rate per 10,000 population to less than 1. Prevalence of leprosy in India is 0.67/ 10, 000 population as on 31st March, 2018. Increase in no. of cases detected is due to various case detection activities conducted under National Leprosy Eradication Programme (NLEP) which are introduced in 2016-17 onward in phase wise manner, few of them are Leprosy Case Detection Campaign (LCDC), Focussed Leprosy Campaign (FLC), ASHA Based Surveillance for Leprosy Suspects (ABSULS) and Sparsh Leprosy Awareness Campaign (SLAC). Further to mention LCDC is best ever campaign for hidden leprosy case detection in the world as on date. This campaign is conducted every year since 2016 - 17 and covers around 50% of population of India. Result of introduction of these activities is in the form of decrease in Grade II disability (G2D) among new cases from 4.48/million population in 2014-15 to 3.34/ million population in 2017-18. Also to mention that percentage of G2D among new cases has also gone down to 3.61% in 2017-2018. This is lowest among all major countries reporting Leprosy cases. This is also reflection of lower no. of hidden cases in the community. We have prevented occurrence of thousands of disabilities due to leprosy in the country. India is on right track to achieve target given by WHO for 2020 which is less than 1 G2D case among new cases/ million population.

During the interview it was said that due to long incubation period of leprosy, India is likely to be free of leprosy by 2030 which is misquoted as elimination in the article. Furthermore, NLEP is in regular communication with leprosy experts and various stakeholders from all over India/ other countries and Govt. & experts do not differ.”

Author’s response:

1. The government does not dispute that more cases are being detected. However, as we have said, the government and several activists who work with leprosy differ on whether this rise can be ascribed to improved case-finding efforts or due to increased incidence.
2. We have corrected the quote to say, “If we continue the surveillance and get more funds India can be leprosy-free by 2030.” We regret the error.

(Ramesh Menon is an author, independent award-winning journalist, documentary film-maker and adjunct professor at Symbiosis Institute of Media and Communication. With inputs from Swagata Yadavar, principal correspondent with IndiaSpend.)

We welcome feedback. Please write to respond@www.health-check.in. We reserve the right to edit responses for language and grammar.